Commentaire descriptif

The language in this sweet and fun story operates entirely from the consciousness of Ruby, the new girl at school. Seated behind Angela, “the girl with the pretty red bow in her hair,” Ruby imitates everything about her. Angela is welcoming at first: “‘I like your bow,’ whispered Angela. ‘I like yours, too,’ whispered Ruby.” But eventually, she writes Ruby a harsh note that makes Ruby cry, “YOU COPIED ME! . . . P.S. I HATE YOUR HAIR THAT WAY.” Children will likely have much to say about Ruby’s dilemma. They may have their own experiences to share, and advice for what Ruby might do. The illustrations beautifully expand on the book’s theme. Ruby is small and odd-looking, with a long, serious face and scrappy haircut. The admirable Angela has a perky nose and profuse blond curls. When Ruby copies Angela’s poem, the children whisper and the teacher’s head droops in despair. All readers will appreciate when Ruby is encouraged to share something original, and “everyone copied her.” This is simply a great story, skillfully told.